| Extensions | Title | Last Name | First Name | Email Address |
| Administration |
| 2107 | Chief | Cerruto | Spencer | scerruto@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2295 | Deputy Chief | Wilcoxson | Alan | awilcoxson@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2108 | Secretary | Gautrau | Christine | cgautrau@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2229 | Lieutenant | Wheeler | Earl | ewheeler@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2316 | Lieutenant | Lafond | Michael | mlafond@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2324 | Lieutenant | Relyea | Katherine | krelyea@newmilfordpolice.org |
| Sergeants |
| 2375 | Sergeant | Brady | James | jbrady@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2118 | Sergeant | Dzamko | James | jdzamko@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2388 | Sergeant | Hannan | Edward | ehannan@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2340 | Sergeant | Giordano | Carla | cgiordano@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2354 | Sergeant | Masi | Frank | fmasi@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2327 | Sergeant | Parziale | Vincenzo | vparziale@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2418 | Sergeant | Guilbeault | Robert | rguilbeault@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2419 | Sergeant | Petersen | David | dpetersen@newmilfordpolice.org |
| Detectives |
| 2127 | Detective | Flockhart | Scott | sflockhart@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2494 | Detective | Lynch | Mark | mlynch@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2485 | Detective | Smith | Nicholas | nsmith@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2451 | Detective | Sin | Dru | dsin@newmilfordpolice.org |
| Patrol Officers |
| 2426 | School Resource Officer | Bollaro | Brian | bbollaro@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2489 | Officer | Begley | Jeannine | jbegley@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2458 | K-9 Officer | Williams | Mark | mwilliams@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2459 | Officer | Syan | Gurdeep | gsyan@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2431 | Officer | Taranto | Louis | ltaranto@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2462 | Officer | Palmer | Steven | spalmer@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2425 | Officer | Kurtz | Ronald | rkurtz@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2442 | Officer | Sin | Kristy | ksin@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2463 | K-9 Officer | Shaw | Christopher | cshaw@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2456 | Officer | Deitz | Matthew | mdeitz@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2453 | Officer | April | Keith | kapril@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2470 | Officer | McIntyre | Dylan | dmcintyre@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2495 | Officer | Rodriguez | Alec | arodriguez@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2498 | Officer | Johnson | Alexander | ajohnson@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2490 | Officer | Kabasakalian | Daniel | dkabasakalian@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2493 | Officer | Legan | John | jlegan@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2480 | School Resource Officer | Ryan | Nicholas | nryan@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2481 | Officer | Stephen | Chad | cstephen@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2486 | Officer | Descoteaux | Richard | rdescoteaux@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2400 | Officer | Wilcoxson | Eric | ewilcoxson@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2401 | Officer | Toromanides | John | jtoromanides@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2497 | K-9 Officer | Lima | Marcello | mlima@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2499 | Officer | Espinal | Cassandra | cespinal@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2402 | Officer | Simmons | Brandon | bsimmons@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2452 | Officer | Lynch | Liam | llynch@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2492 | Officer | Rodrigues | Aline | arodrigues@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2403 | Officer | Caldara | Tyler | tcaldara@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2491 | Officer | Buonanno | Philip | pbuonanno@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2420 | Officer | Muckerman | Brandon | bmuckerman@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2444 | Officer | Olsson | Evan | eolsson@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2443 | Officer | Brunelli | Joseph | jbrunelli@newmilfordpolice.org |
| Dispatchers |
| | Communications Supervisor | Walsh | Christine | cwalsh@newmilfordpolice.org |
| | Dispatcher | Dzamko | Matthew | mdzamko@newmilfordpolice.org |
| | Dispatcher | Halloran | Stayce | sholloran@newmilfordpolice.org |
| | Dispatcher | Ronan | Jason | jronan@newmilfordpolice.org |
| | Dispatcher | Warner | Scott | jreynolds@newmilfordpolice.org |
| | Dispatcher | Kellog | Samantha | skellog@newmilfordpolice.org |
| | Dispatcher | Manning | Ginger | gmanning@newmilfordpolice.org |
| | Dispatcher | Quinn | Teresa | tquinn@newmilfordpolice.org |
| | Dispatcher | Joseph | Curtis | cjoseph@newmilfordpolice.org |
| Records |
| 2149 | Records | Dumas | Stephanie | nmpdrecords@newmilfordpolice.org |
| 2198 | Records | Gordon | Lori | nmpdrecords@newmilfordpolice.org |
| PEO |
| 2810 | Parking Enforcement Officer | Dougherty | Denise | ddougherty@newmilfordpolice.org |
| COO |
| 2473 | Community Outreach Officer | Schneider | Jake | jschneider@newmilfordpolice.org |
